What is no-fault divorce?
No-fault divorce is a divorce case in which neither party is required to demonstrate wrongdoing, or “fault”. In the UK currently, people wishing to divorce must prove that their marriage has irrevocably broken down; this is known as having “grounds for divorce”.
Grounds for divorce include adultery, unreasonable behaviour, desertion, or extended periods of separation; this is two years of consensual separation or five years of non-consensual separation.
In legal terms, divorce currently requires evidence that at least one of the spouses has somehow breached their marital contract.
No fault-divorce bill timeline
- January 2020: The Divorce, Dissolution and Separation Bill enters parliament on the 7th January 2020.
- October 2019: The Queen’s speech puts no-fault divorce back on the parliamentary agenda with the reintroduction of the Divorce, Dissolution and Separation Bill. MPs must start from scratch to get the bill passed.
- September 2019: Prorogation of Parliament sees the Divorce, Dissolution and Separation Bill dropped.
- July 2019: Following the Conservative Party Leadership election and selection of Boris Johnson as leader in 2019, David Gauke resigns from his position as Justice Secretary.
- April 2019: David Gauke, commits to no-fault divorce “becoming law as soon as parliamentary time allows’
- September 2018: Following increased interest as a result of the Owens case, UK Justice Secretary, David Gauke, launches ‘public debate’ on proposals to modernise the UK divorce process.
- April 2018: The Owens divorce case makes further headlines, as an unhappy spouse is forced to remain married because the Supreme Court ruled that “joyless marriage is not grounds for divorce”. Support for no-fault divorce sees a boost.
- 2015: The Tini Owens case sees an initial hearing dismiss the divorce petition, despite Owens providing 27 examples of why the marriage was irrevocably broken down. The judge ruled her case was “flimsy and exaggerated”
- 1996: The Family Law Act 1996 introduced no-fault divorce. This was repealed because it was deemed unworkable. Despite this, it had been widely supported by lawyers, the judiciary and relationship charities.
- 1989: The Children Act 1989 rules that “the child’s welfare shall always be the court’s paramount consideration” during a divorce.
- 1973: Under the Matrimonial Causes Act 1973 in England and Wales, anyone seeking a divorce must prove their spouse is at fault.
- 1969: The Divorce Reform Act passes, allowing couples to divorce if they have been separated for 2 years consensually, or 5 years without consent from both spouses.
Why no-fault divorce?
Not every marriage that breaks down does so as a result of wrongdoing or “fault”, insofar as current legislation defines it. Many couples simply become unhappy through no direct fault of an individual.
Those in favour of no-fault divorce believe it will reduce conflict, stress and other emotional difficulties commonly associated with the divorce process. Instead, it allows the focus to be placed on central issues, including property and assets, finances and, of course, children.
How many divorces are fault-based in the UK?
According to a BBC study in 2018, there were more fault-based divorces than non-fault based divorces – however, this may not be a reliable statistic, as many couples may claim fault when it does not exist as a means of speeding up their divorce.
Even so, there were still over 45,000 non-fault divorces, which certainly shows a need for an accessible no-fault solution.
The same BBC study found that 70% of couples felt a fault-based divorce made the process more “bitter”. 21% said that it made it more difficult to agree arrangements for children, and 31% said it made it harder to agree finances.
How no-fault divorce can benefit children
According to the Children Act, introduced to the UK in 1989:
When a court determines any question with respect to—-
- the upbringing of a child; or
- the administration of a child’s property or the application of any income arising from it,
the child’s welfare shall always be the court’s paramount consideration.
In addition to this, the legislation also says:
In any proceedings in which any question with respect to the upbringing of a child arises, the court shall have regard to the general principle that any delay in determining the question is likely to prejudice the welfare of the child.
Put simply, the welfare of children must always come first in a divorce. The problem here is that an acrimonious divorce can unfortunately be traumatic and stressful for children involved.
The introduction of no-fault divorce removes the need to allocate blame, and therefore helps reduce animosity and gives divorcing couples a better platform to reach an amicable and positive resolution for all involved.
What are the arguments against no-fault divorce?
Not everyone is in favour of no-fault divorce in the UK. Some opponents to the law believe that it would allow spouses at fault to be granted divorce terms which do not take their wrongdoing into account.
Another common issue raised with no-fault divorce is the belief that it would lead to a dramatic increase in UK divorce rate. However, studies by Stephanie Coontz, a professor at Evergreen State College in the USA, stated that “in the years since no-fault divorce became well-nigh universal, the national divorce rate has fallen.”
Will no-fault divorce make divorcing easier?
No-fault divorce will mean that grounds for divorce are extended beyond adultery, unreasonable behaviour and desertion, but will still require divorcing couples to demonstrate that their marriage has irretrievably broken down. Put simply, it is not expected to allow couples to divorce without proper consideration.
Is no-fault divorce available in the UK?
As of December 2019, the UK has a fault-based system of divorce in place. For a divorce to go ahead, couples need to assign some kind of blame for the breakdown of the marriage, unless they are happy to wait between 2-5 years for a no-fault divorce. No-fault divorce is not currently part of UK family law; however, this is set to change.
When will no fault divorce begin in the UK?
The UK government has committed to the introduction of no-fault divorce in the UK, following years of campaigning from the legal community. As of December 2019, there is no fixed date for this legislation to be introduced.
The government stated that no fault-divorce will be introduced “as soon as parliamentary time becomes available.” With Brexit, elections and other major political issues dominating parliament for most of 2019, it is not currently clear when this will be.
When did different countries introduce no-fault divorce?
*In the United States, each state has its own legislation for divorce and therefore introduced no-fault divorce at different times. For example, California first introduced no-fault divorce in 1970, while New York only introduced it as recently as 2010.
How much does a no-fault divorce cost?
As with any divorce, it is impossible to determine a total cost without first taking into consideration the specific circumstances surrounding your case. In the United States, however, it has been argued that the overall costs for a no-fault divorce are significantly lower than
divorces where extensive litigation is required to settle disputes and ultimately determine fault.
What else does the no-fault divorce bill include?
In addition to removing the necessity for blame in order to form grounds for divorce, the no-fault divorce bill also includes the following additional proposals:
- Remove the opportunity to contest - there would still be some legal grounds for challenging an application.
- Introduce a minimum six month time frame from petition stage to Decree Absolute
- Retain the two-stage decree process – it would still be necessary to apply separately for the Decree Nisi and Decree Absolute
- Retain the bar on divorce and dissolution applications in the first year.
- Modernise the language used within the divorce process.
Will Brexit delay no-fault divorce?
Despite the reintroduction of the Divorce, Dissolution and Separation Bill in 2019, Brexit poses a threat to its passing in the short term.
UK Parliament has been occupied with the United Kingdom’s departure from the EU since 2016. Recent commitments have been made to ensure no-fault divorce legislation will happen as soon as parliamentary time allows; however, with Brexit, nobody yet knows when this time will be available.
Jane Robey, CEO of National Family Mediation says “Plans to introduce ‘no fault’ divorce are very welcome, and long overdue. But our fear is that they will become still more overdue as a result of the Parliamentary timetable being log-jammed, ironically by the UK’s own divorce - from the EU.”
Last Updated 27th January 2020Back to blog